Day 9: Fudge

In our house, we do not partake of fudge often. The husband dislikes it strongly. You could say he hates it, but hate is such a strong word that we discourage its use. The boys like fudge ok and I like it in small quantities. Do you remember when fudge was quite a “thing”? There used to be a place in downtown Baltimore in the touristy part that sold fudge and the employees would sing and act while they stirred the fudge on a huge marble table with giant paddles. I always loved watching that show, plus they gave out samples at the end.


Good fudge has a reputation for being difficult, though there are many simplified recipes out there, I really wanted to make a true fudge, one that did not rely on shortcuts. It actually took quite a bit of digging to find a recipe that only used sugar, chocolate, and cream. Ok, there’s a little bit of corn syrup in there as well, but I am finding that most candy recipes call for this ingredient. It keeps sugar crystals from forming in candies and since it is not as bad as that high fructose stuff, I have made my peace with it.


We found that fudge is really not all that difficult to make. Like many of the candies we have made, all the ingredients go into the pot, everything gets stirred up until it is combined, and then you boil it until it reaches the right temperature.

In the case of fudge, after that temp is achieved, it then has to sit around until it has cooled to a certain temp as well. Then, it has to be beaten until thick (hence the giant paddles at the store).


I wouldn’t say it was hard, just time consuming, though most of the time is spent waiting around.


In the end, we had some really great fudge. It was creamy and smooth and not as sweet as other fudges we have had. The beating also made the texture a little bit lighter. Walnuts were a great addition.


Well, this recipe did not change the husband’s mind about fudge. He still really dislikes it, but I personally really liked this fudge and the boys liked it, too. I thought it was better than most other fudges out there and would make it again. Next time, I want to try making it with goat milk. It would be fun to play with different flavors and mix-ins. Any suggestions?


Posted on December 17, 2014, in Family Fun, Holiday and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink. 11 Comments.

  1. The phrase “fudge for tourists” reminds me of the mediocre version in the shops in Gatlinburg. As a child watching it be made, I figured it would be heavenly, like the stuff my grandmother made. When the free samples were handed round, I was disappointed. Your fudge does not disappoint!

  2. Had some homemade goats milk fudge the other day. It was the best fudge I’ve ever had. It was so light, yet yummy.

  3. Yes, I remember the ‘performance’ workers did while making the fudge. It was entertaining (but I still didn’t buy any of their fudge).

  4. It looks positively divine to me! I once had a recipe for black forest fudge where you added plump dried sour cherries – I think they would make a great mix in for this recipe as well.

  5. I love chocolate and salt. Perhaps lightly salted sunflower seeds?

  6. I like the idea of adding dried cherries. Or pecans. Walnuts are traditional I think, and they are also good!

  7. I’m with the others – I like dried fruit in fudge. Maybe even some candied orange peel? Yours looks delicious!

  8. Just chocolate and nuts!!

  9. Fudge isn’t my first choice of candies either. It’s generally too sweet for me, just too much all around. But making it yourself would since the sweetness factor! Good plan.

  10. Peanut butter fudge is the best, but the sweetness is usually what gets to me, too…. I did have a creamy pumpkin fudge once that was truly amazing. Walnuts would be good in that as well….

Tell me what you think!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: